When hunger hits and you want something amazing, Benny’s Pizza and Burgers is the place to go. Located in Perryopolis, Pennsylvania, it’s a local favorite. They serve dishes that are true to classic American comfort food for benny’s pizza and burgers menu.
Exploring Benny’s online menu is a flavorful journey. They offer hand-tossed pizzas and juicy burgers. Their food shows their commitment to quality and passion for cooking.
Benny’s is more than a restaurant; it’s a beloved spot in the community. Their menu has something for everyone, making sure you find something tasty.
Table of contents
Overview of Benny’s Pizza and Burgers
Learn about a local gem that has won the hearts of many. Benny’s Pizza and Burgers is more than a place to eat. It’s a mix of passion, tradition, and great flavors.
A Brief History of Benny’s
What began as a small pizzeria has grown into a favorite spot. Our menu has changed over time, showing our dedication to quality and making customers happy. With a 87% positive food review rating, Benny’s keeps delivering amazing meals to our fans.
- Founded as a local pizzeria
- Expanded to full-service restaurant
- Developed diverse dine-in menu
- Introduced extensive takeout options
What Makes Benny’s Unique?
Benny’s stands out among other local places. Our commitment to quality shines in every dish. We’ve hit a 97% order accuracy and keep an 88% on-time delivery rate for takeout.
“Great food isn’t just about taste – it’s about passion, quality, and creating memorable dining experiences.” – Benny’s Founder
Our menu meets many tastes and dietary needs. Whether you want a classic pizza or something vegetarian, we have it. Our brick oven pizzas and burgers are made with care, making us a favorite in the community.
| Menu Highlight | Price |
|---|---|
| Cauliflower Pizza | $14.99+ |
| Small Pizza (14″) | $15.99+ |
| Mozzarella Sticks | $9.99+ |
Join us and see why Benny’s is a top choice for food lovers!
Appetizers to Start Your Meal
Start your meal at Benny’s with our delicious appetizers. Our menu items are made to excite your taste buds. They’re great for sharing or enjoying by yourself, whether you order online or dine in.
Classic Fried Mozzarella Sticks
Our restaurant is known for starting meals off right. Our golden-brown mozzarella sticks are a hit. They come with:
- Crispy breaded exterior
- Gooey, melted cheese inside
- Served with zesty marinara sauce
Buffalo Wings with Dipping Sauces
Get your taste buds ready for our famous buffalo wings. Choose from different heat levels to match your taste:
| Wing Flavor | Heat Level | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Hot | Spicy | $19.00 |
| Honey Garlic | Mild | $19.00 |
| BBQ | Sweet | $19.00 |
Garlic Knots for Bread Lovers
Soft, pillowy bread bites with garlic butter and parmesan cheese. These garlic knots are a must-try, available online or in our restaurant.
“Our appetizers are more than just starters – they’re the beginning of a delicious journey!” – Benny’s Chef
Pizza Selection: A Slice of Heaven
Explore Benny’s pizza and burgers menu, where every slice has a story. Our online menu has a wide selection to please all pizza fans.
Pizza at Benny’s is more than a meal; it’s an adventure. Our brick oven pizzas have crispy crusts and melted cheese. They take your taste buds to a flavor paradise.
Signature Pizzas You Must Try
Check out our top pizza picks:
- Classic Margherita with fresh basil and mozzarella
- Spicy Buffalo Chicken with zesty sauce
- Unique Malawach Pizza with a Middle Eastern twist
Customizing Your Own Pizza
Be your own pizza chef. Our customizable option lets you make your dream pizza with:
- Choose from multiple sauce bases
- Select your favorite cheese blend
- Pick from 20+ premium toppings
Vegan and Gluten-Free Options
We offer delicious pizzas for everyone. Our menu includes:
| Dietary Option | Crust Type | Available Toppings |
|---|---|---|
| Vegan Pizza | Plant-based crust | Vegan cheese, vegetable medley |
| Gluten-Free Pizza | Cauliflower crust | Standard and specialty toppings |
“At Benny’s, we believe great pizza brings people together!” – Benny Tesoro
Pro tip: Our 28-inch pizzas are larger than a traffic pylon and perfect for sharing!
Signature Burgers: The Best in Town
Benny’s restaurant menu offers a burger experience that will satisfy even the most discerning food lovers. Our dine-in menu and takeout options showcase an incredible range of burger selections. They are designed to tantalize your taste buds and deliver maximum flavor.
Burger lovers will find something special in our carefully crafted selection. Each burger is prepared with premium ingredients and expert techniques. These elevate the classic American meal.
Classic Cheeseburger: A Timeless Favorite
Our Classic Cheeseburger represents the gold standard of burger perfection. Highlights include:
- 100% Angus beef patty
- Melted cheddar cheese
- Fresh lettuce and tomato
- Signature house sauce
Specialty Burgers with Unique Toppings
For adventurous eaters, our specialty burgers offer extraordinary flavor combinations. Get ready to explore unexpected taste experiences!
“Our specialty burgers are like a culinary adventure between two buns!” – Chef Mike
Vegetarian and Plant-Based Options
We understand diverse dietary preferences. Our vegetarian and plant-based burgers deliver incredible taste without compromise:
- Impossible Burger with all the traditional burger fixings
- Black bean veggie burger
- Portobello mushroom burger
Whether you’re dining in or choosing takeout options, Benny’s restaurant menu ensures every burger lover finds their perfect meal.
Salads and Sides for a Balanced Meal
At Benny’s Pizza and Burgers, we know a great meal is balanced. We offer more than just pizza and burgers. Our salads and sides add a perfect touch to your meal.
Eating out doesn’t mean you have to skip nutrition. Our sides and salads are a refreshing choice. You can order online or dine in to find something for every taste.
Fresh Garden Salad: Crisp and Customizable
Our fresh garden salad is the perfect healthy side. You can pick your favorite toppings and dressings to make it just right.
- Mixed organic greens
- Cherry tomatoes
- Cucumber slices
- Choice of premium dressings
Crispy Fries: A Flavor Sensation
Want something crispy? Our French and sweet potato fries are perfect for burger and pizza fans.
| Fry Type | Price | Size Options |
|---|---|---|
| Classic French Fries | $4.99 | Small, Medium, Large |
| Sweet Potato Fries | $5.49 | Small, Medium, Large |
Onion Rings: The Perfect Sidekick
No meal is complete without our famous onion rings. Golden, crispy, and utterly irresistible, they’re the perfect match for any dish.
“Our onion rings are so good, they might just steal the show!” – Chef Benny
Whether you’re ordering online or dining in, our salads and sides make your meal complete. They offer more than just pizza and burgers.
Desserts to Satisfy Your Sweet Tooth
Craving something sweet after your meal? Benny’s pizza and burgers menu has just what you need. Our dessert selection will tantalize your taste buds and end your meal on a high note.
Our online menu offers a wide range of desserts for every taste. From classic treats to seasonal specials, we’ve got a food selection that will leave you with a sweet memory.
Homemade Tiramisu: A Classic Delight
Try our signature homemade tiramisu. It’s a decadent mix of:
- Delicate coffee-soaked ladyfingers
- Creamy mascarpone cheese
- Dusting of rich cocoa powder
Classic New York Cheesecake: Smooth and Irresistible
Our New York-style cheesecake is a must-try. It’s known for its:
- Velvety smooth texture
- Graham cracker crust
- Handcrafted daily in our kitchen
Seasonal Desserts: Always Exciting and Fresh
Our team creates unique seasonal desserts. They highlight the best flavors of each season. These limited-time treats add a fun twist to our regular menu.
“Every dessert tells a story of flavor, crafted with passion and precision.” – Benny’s Pastry Chef
| Dessert Name | Price | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Homemade Tiramisu | $10 | Classic Italian dessert with layers of coffee and mascarpone |
| New York Cheesecake | $9 | Rich, creamy cheesecake with graham cracker crust |
| Seasonal Special | $11 | Chef’s rotating seasonal creation |
Whether you’re dining in or taking out, our desserts will make your Benny’s experience even better. Come by and enjoy a sweet treat that will have you coming back for more!
Beverages to Complement Your Meal
At Benny’s Pizza and Burgers, we offer more than just food. The right drink can make your meal even better. This is true whether you’re dining in or taking food to go.
Soft Drinks and Juices
Find the perfect drink to quench your thirst. Our menu has classic soft drinks, fresh juices, and sparkling drinks for everyone. You can choose from:
- Classic Coca-Cola products
- Fresh orange and apple juices
- Sparkling water varieties
- Seasonal fruit punch
Craft Beers and Local Brews
Beer lovers will enjoy our selection of craft and local brews. Each beer is chosen to pair well with our pizzas and burgers. Our beer list includes:
- Local microbrewery selections
- Rotating seasonal craft beers
- Domestic and imported options
Specialty Lemonades and Iced Teas
Try our unique house-made drinks for something special. We’re proud of our creative drinks that add to your meal:
- Lavender mint lemonade
- Strawberry basil iced tea
- Classic Arnold Palmer
- Seasonal fruit-infused drinks
“Great food deserves great drinks – and we deliver on both!” – Benny’s Beverage Team
Family Meal Deals and Combos
Dining out with family is now easier at Benny’s Pizza and Burgers. Our family meal deals are perfect for every appetite and budget. Whether you want the best pizza and burgers or easy meal options, we’ve got you covered.
Pizza and Burger Combos That Delight
Our menu items offer great value with combos. You can mix and match your favorite dishes. Here are some tasty options:
- Family Pizza & Burger Pack
- Combo Meal with 2 Large Pizzas
- Burger Lovers Feast
- Vegetarian Combo Option
Family Packs for Easy Ordering
Order online with ease and enjoy our family packs. Perfect for game nights, family dinners, or casual gatherings. Our packages include:
- 4-Person Pizza Package
- Family Burger Bundle
- Mixed Appetizer Platter
Promotions and Specials
“Great food doesn’t have to break the bank!” – Benny’s Promise
Stay updated on our rotating specials and seasonal promotions. Enjoy discounted combo meals and limited-time offers. We make sure you get the best value at Benny’s Pizza and Burgers.
Convenient curbside pickup makes enjoying your favorite meals easy. Just place your order online and pick up your delicious feast!
Catering Options for Events
Planning an event can be stressful, but Benny’s pizza and burgers menu makes catering easy. Our catering services ensure your gatherings are deliciously memorable. We offer a food selection that keeps everyone satisfied.
Custom Catering Menus to Fit Your Needs
We know every event is unique. Our online menu offers flexible catering options to match your needs:
- Office lunch parties
- Birthday celebrations
- Corporate events
- Family gatherings
Simple Ordering Process
Booking your event catering with Benny’s is easy. You can choose from our pre-designed packages or create a custom spread. This ensures your guests’ tastes are perfectly met.
| Catering Package | Serves | Price Range |
|---|---|---|
| Pizza Party Pack | 10-15 people | $129.99 |
| Burger Bash | 8-12 people | $149.99 |
| Mixed Meal Combo | 15-20 people | $199.99 |
What Our Customers Say
“Benny’s catering made our company picnic incredible. The food was hot, delicious, and everyone was impressed!” – Sarah K., Marketing Director
Ready to make your next event unforgettable? Contact our catering team today. Let us handle the delicious details!
Conclusion: Why You Should Visit Benny’s
Your journey through Benny’s menu is just starting. Our dine-in menu has something special for everyone. You’ll find new favorites with each visit. We offer everything from plant-based dishes to hearty classics.
Our takeout options are perfect for those on the go. Whether you need a quick lunch or a family dinner, we’ve got you covered. We serve high-quality meals with fresh ingredients and creative recipes.
Recap of Menu Highlights
At Benny’s, variety is our focus. 75% of our menu is vegetarian and vegan. You’ll love our signature pizzas, juicy burgers, and creative sides. Each dish is made with care and precision.For more great recipes please click here.
Customer Experience and Service
Visit us at 175-63 Hillside Ave in Jamaica, NY. Our customers return because of our great service and food. We’re more than a restaurant; we’re a place where memories are made.
How to Find Benny’s Pizza and Burgers
Ready to try our menu? Find us at 175-63 Hillside Ave, Jamaica, NY 11432. We offer dine-in, takeout, and online ordering. Come see why Benny’s is a favorite local spot.